What are the Differences between Coaching and Mentoring that We Should Be Aware of?

Even though the terms are often used interchangeably, coaching and mentoring are two very different things. While choosing between coaching and mentoring for developing skills or advancing careers, we must remember that both roles require similar qualities and competence but may vary widely in structure and overall outcome. Some key differences between coaching and mentoring have been illustrated below:

1. Timeframe and Structure:

When engaging in a coaching and mentoring comparison, it is important to take stock of the timeframe and design of the two relationships.

Coaching:

A coaching relationship or program is typically targeted and short-term, which may vary from 3 months to 1 year. These programs adhere to a strict structural framework and timeline, with formal, scheduled meetings and regular performance evaluations.

Mentoring:

Mentoring relationships on the other hand are lasting and long-term, with no strict timelines. Leadership mentoring can last for 2-3 years while creativity mentoring can last longer than 5 years. Mentoring meets tend to be less formal and can be fixed in accordance to the needs of mentees.

2. Focus and Agenda:

The benefits of coaching and mentoring cannot be compared without knowing the focus and the agenda of the two programs separately.

Coaching:

In this era of super competitive workplace culture, coaching programs tend to be performance driven, to help individuals improve their work-performance and skills. The coaching agenda is co-created by both the coach and the pupil to address their specific needs.

Mentoring:

Mentoring programs are driven by holistic development of individuals and focus not only on their on-job performance enhancement but also their personal growth. A mentoring program agenda is essentially fixed by the mentee.

3. Expertise and Outcome:

Mentoring and coaching in the workplace can differ depending upon the expertise and competence of the coach or mentor, as well as on the desired outcomes of the programs.

Coaching:

Outcomes of coaching programs are clear, specific, and measurable. A coach is specifically employed on the basis of their expertise in areas that can steer employees or pupils towards this program objective.

Mentoring:

Since the objectives of the mentoring programs include overall development of mentees, outcomes of mentoring programs are not so specific or measurable and can change and shift over time. Mentors are selected not only based on their expertise or skills but also their seniority and experience.

Be it performance coaching and mentoring or business coaching and mentoring, even though the relations follow different paths and are structured differently, in the end both the programs are designed to help individuals grow professionally and personally.

Graphic Attribute: Image by Freepik